Suffolk County, NY
Living in Bay Shore
A revived Main Street, Fire Island ferries and grand old homes on shady streets. Bay Shore is one of the South Shore's busiest hamlets.
What Bay Shore is like
Bay Shore has restaurants and shops along Main Street, a marina on the Great South Bay and ferries to Fire Island. Homes range from Victorians and colonials to capes and ranches.
Getting around
The Bay Shore LIRR station on the Montauk Branch, Sunrise Highway and the Southern State and Sagtikos Parkways all serve the area.
Neighborhoods nearby
- Bay Shore
- Brightwaters
- West Islip
- Islip
- North Bay Shore
- Brentwood
Homes we are selling in Bay Shore
When we list a home in Bay Shore, it shows up here first. Want a heads-up before it hits the big sites? Text us what you are looking for.
New listings in Bay Shore
What’s your Bay Shore home worth?
Bay Shore questions
Do you work with buyers and sellers in Bay Shore?
Yes. Tommy and Jodi help people buy and sell in Bay Shore and across Western and Central Suffolk, from our office at 35 Arkay Drive in Hauppauge.
How fast do you answer?
Text either of us any time. We answer our own phones, and if we are with a client we text you back as soon as we can.
Can you tell me what my Bay Shore home is worth?
Yes, for free. Fill out the short form on this page or text us your address, and we will look at recent nearby sales and get back to you.